|
|
A
free 86 page self-teaching textbook based on the above method
is available. It features clear explanations of grammar
concepts, and takes you through a staged approach to sentence
structure recognition. There are extensive sentence collections
(taken from classic English writers) to use for practice.
The textbook also applies these principles to punctuation.
Supplemental readings from classic traditional grammar
books are included.
Please
click here for
details.
Listen to audio files of Supporting Lectures on this Workbook: Lecture 1: Parallelism - Download Lecture 2: Phrases and Clauses - Download
Lecture 3: Sentence Structure
- Download
|
In
the current state of education, Language Arts teachers who wish
to teach grammar are in a quandary. Because
grammar is no longer a systematic part of the curriculum in
most school districts, the grammar teacher is faced with students
who have no prior knowledge of the subject. The quandary, then, is to find a lesson that
is self-contained, brief, and educationally useful. I have faced this quandary with my first-year
university students for quite a few years now, and suggest the
following as just one of many possible ways of dealing with this
quandary.
Students
today have little recognition of sentence segmentation. They tend to think of a sentence as an ongoing
stream, rather than as an assembly of discretely structured
pieces.
Therefore,
it is a good beginning in grammar simply to have the students
learn to recognize word clusters as specific discrete segments
which compose the sentence. Teach them to see that a sentence
consists of definite clusters, which are called clauses and
phrases.
Each
clause and each phrase has its own definite integrity.
It is to some degree a closed unit.
This
internal unity can be demonstrated in a few ways, first, by
the fact that clauses and phrases function
as a closed piece. If you take an adjectival phrase, for example,
it is the phrase as a
whole that performs the adjective function.
The phrase is one unit.
In
addition, phrases move around the sentence as one complete piece. In revising, one inserts, moves or deletes phrases;
one doesn’t tear a phrase apart and remove half and leave half in
the sentence.
If you can teach students to see the solid clusters within the
sentence, that alone is one way out of the quandary of grammar
teaching.
In
my experience, the three following grammatical structures make
for a compact, complete, and self-contained grammar unit:
|
1)
|
The prepositional phrase: it starts on each preposition and continues
until the next following noun.
Instruct students to bracket each prepositional phrase.
|
|
2)
|
Clause conjunctions. These come in two varieties, the kind that produce
dependent clauses (by far the majority) and the simpler,
more neutral ones that do not create dependency.
Students should underline all clause conjunctions.
|
|
3)
|
Dependent
clauses: these occur
whenever a clause is headed by a dependent clause conjunction.
Ask students to put square brackets around dependent
clauses.
|
The following are illustrations of this diagramming system:
Jane
united a composure (of temper) (with a uniform cheerfulness)
(of manner,) [which would guard her] (from the suspicions)
(of the impertinent). {Jane Austen}
Your mother will never see you again [if you do not
marry Mr Collins], and I will never see you again [if
you do]. {Jane Austen}
(In those days,) (in such cases,)
men did not think (of germs and infections,) but (of sins.)
{H. G. Wells}
The obscurity [that prevails so much] (among philosophical
writers) is actually caused (by the indistinctness) (of their
ideas.) {Hugh Blair}
We are pleased (with an author) [who frees us] (from
all fatigue) (of searching) (for his meaning,) [who
carries us] (through his subject) (without any difficulty
or confusion,) [whose style flows always] (like a slow
stream.) {Hugh Blair}
Please note the choice of classic authors (Austen, Wells, Blair)
for grammar study. Classic authors use a rationalist style that
makes for very prominent segmentation. This approach to sentence
analysis will take your students from being structurally unaware
to being structurally aware. The approach is an excellent precursor
to the study of punctuation errors.